Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta: Authentic Flavors in West Islip
Located at 636 Union Blvd in West Islip, NY, Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta is a beloved neighborhood gem known for its inviting atmosphere and outstanding cuisine. The friendly staff and hands-on owner create a warm environment that's hard to beat. Patrons rave about the delicious offerings, especially the Penne Alla Vodka and unique options like macaroni and cheese pizza. It's a place where locals gather, and even visitors from afar, like those from Türkiye, find joy in the flavors. With a commitment to community and exceptional service, this eatery is a must-visit for pizza lovers and pasta enthusiasts alike.
Photos & Gallery
Popular Menu Items
Mixed Slices
Margarita Pizza
Chicken Francese
Italian Cold Cut Combo
Stuffed Slice
Bacon Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Alfredo Pizza Grandma Pizza Slice
Tartufo
Stuffed Clams
Veggie Pizza Slice
Pasta with Broccoli Rabe
French Fry & Bacon Pizza
Pepperoni Roll and BBQ Chicken Pizza
Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta: Reviews & Ratings
Amazing neighborhood restaurant with friendly staff and some of the best tasting pizza I've ever had... and I've had a lot. Gotta try the Penne Alla Vodka. It's very tasty. You won't go wrong here.
The best local pizza in town. Fantastic selection of product, great staff, I go out of my way to eat here on a regular basis signed the second half of 2024
I came here all the way from Türkiye. My husband has been showing me around Long Island, and we stopped here on the way to the beach. The pizza is amazing; I love the macaroni and cheese pizza. Two birds, one stone! It's also nice to see that they support the police department!
Great food!! Service is excellent (ask for Ashley when she's there.) Owner is also a great guy, on site, hands on, and lots of involvement with the local community
This was my first eatery I tried when stopping in Bay Shore for work. I ended up going here a lot. The options are great and it's quick and easy. If it isn't broke, don't fix it.
Location
-
636 Union Blvd #3113, West Islip, NY 11795, United States Hotline: +1 631-661-6246
If you find yourself in West Islip, NY, make it a point to visit Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta, a gem nestled at 636 Union Blvd #3113. This local eatery stands out not just for its inviting atmosphere but also for its delicious offerings that have won the hearts of many. With a phone call to +1 631-661-6246, you can dive straight into a culinary experience that boasts some of the community’s best flavors.
Patrons rave about the friendly staff and the authentically crafted pizzas that have become a staple in the neighborhood. One enthusiastic customer, Richard Ferrick, highlights the pizza as “some of the best tasting” he’s ever had — a testament that can hardly be overlooked. And if you're adventurous, his recommendation of the Penne Alla Vodka promises a rich and satisfying flavor that’s sure to leave you craving more.
The macaroni and cheese pizza has also taken the spotlight, captivating diners like Ezgi Bebek who traveled all the way from Türkiye just to indulge in the unique dish. It's not just about the food, but also about the experience, as she enjoyed this savory fusion while supporting a local eatery that gives back to the community, including the local police department.
Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta has quickly become a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike. As Jason McMahon expresses, it’s hard to ignore the “fantastic selection” and the loving, attentive service provided by the staff. For those seeking comfort food that feels like home, this restaurant delivers with passion and pride. Even Glider RS, who stumbled upon the eatery during a work trip, found himself returning for its quick, delicious options that don’t fail to impress.
The involvement of the owner, noted for his hands-on approach and commitment to local community ties, adds an authentic charm to the experience. You might even want to ask for Ashley, who has been highlighted for her exceptional service by regular visitors like Matt Lopez.
Whether you are a pizza aficionado or you’re simply searching for a cozy spot to enjoy a fulfilling meal, Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta caters to all palettes and promises a memorable dining experience. So, next time you’re in the area, don’t hesitate to stop in—your taste buds will thank you.
- Accessibility
- Has wheelchair-accessible car park
- Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
- Has wheelchair-accessible seating
- Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
- Service options
- Has outdoor seating
- Offers kerbside pickup
- Has no-contact delivery
- Offers delivery
- Offers takeaway
- Serves dine-in
- Payments
- Accepts credit cards
- Accepts debit cards
- Accepts NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards